Skip to content

Decision Lab

Three practice cases on the arithmetic of a trade plan: what leverage changes, what commission does to a fixed risk budget, and how a late fill or a currency conversion can push a loss past the plan. Each case asks for a prediction and how sure you are, shows the answer worked out by the calculators' own code, explains it, then sets a fresh variation with new numbers.

The cases test how a plan's numbers are read. They do not measure trading skill or readiness to trade, and nothing is stored: answers stay on this page and clear when it reloads. Every case uses a USD account, the calculators' fixed reference prices and a 0.01-lot minimum and step, measures the stop from the entry fill price and leaves out swap.

1. The same position at different leverage

Leverage decides how much margin a position holds. The question is what else it changes.

1.00 lots of GBP/USD at 1.3335 on a USD account. The account's leverage goes from 1:100 to 1:300; the position stays the same size.

Which of these changes: the margin held, or the loss on a 30-pip move against the position?
How sure are you?

2. Commission against a fixed risk budget

A size worked out from the stop alone has room for a per-lot commission only when rounding down happens to leave enough.

A $2,000 USD account risks 1% ($20.00) on EUR/USD at 1.1253 with a 20-pip stop, where a pip on 1 lot is worth $10.00. The plan divides the budget by the loss per lot at the stop (20 pips × $10.00) and rounds down: 0.10 lots. The broker charges $7.00 per lot, round trip.

Does 0.10 lots stay within the $20.00 budget at the stop once commission is charged?
How sure are you?

3. When the loss passes the plan

With a standard stop, the loss at the stop is a plan, not a cap: a late fill or the currency conversion can move it.

A short position of 2.00 lots of USD/JPY at 158.02 on a USD account has a 50-pip stop at 158.52. The loss is in yen and converts into dollars at the USD/JPY price.

Converted at the stop price, where the loss is realised, is the dollar loss larger or smaller than converted at the entry price?
How sure are you?

The same arithmetic runs in the Margin Calculator and the Position Size Calculator, and the position sizing article works through it step by step.